'In Putin's Russia and Xi Jinping's China, authoritarianism has become a pathway to meritocracy.’ Discuss

The essay will be marked on the following general criteria:

1. Argumentation and writing: 50%.

Make sure that your argument is sustained throughout the essay. You should make a case in your essay, rather than simply telling a story. Keep your essay focused on the proposition. ‘Discuss’ means discuss the validity of the proposition, not a series of tangential observations. Look carefully at the precise words of the proposition (which is to be the title of the essay), and make sure that your entire essay is a response to it. At the very least, your essay should have a clear statement in the opening paragraphs along the lines of: 'This essay argues that…' followed by an assertion that relates clearly to the proposition, and that is substantiated in the rest of the essay.

At all costs, avoid digressions from the topic. Imagine, as you are writing, that you are trying to convince an extremely sceptical reader of your viewpoint. Try to show an awareness of possible contrary arguments, particularly in the opening.

An essay without a clear argument is extremely unlikely to get above a H3.

Make sure that each paragraph addresses a specific idea. Usually, this idea will be clearly set out in the opening sentence (the topic sentence).

2. Research: 50%

Research should include at least 7 secondary sources (either refereed academic articles or academic books).

Short book reviews and articles on the internet may provide useful information, but they will not count towards the 7 secondary sources

Make sure that your research demonstrates engagement with the course. Listen to the lectures most relevant to the topic, and review the required and additional readings for that week.

Each of the following propositions and questions can be answered in many ways. There is no prescribed, ‘correct’ answer.

The list of suggested issues that follows each proposition is intended as a starting point for your research and to give you a sense of the possibilities of the topic. It is not intended as a structure or as a comprehensive guide for your response. Do NOT use the topics as subheadings.

1. 'In Putin's Russia and Xi Jinping's China, authoritarianism has become a pathway to meritocracy.’ Discuss

Issues you might address include:

• Daniel Bell’s The China Model: Political Meritocracy and the Limits of Democracy (2018, 2^nd edition available on Latrobe library catalogue)
• Andrew Nathan’s critique of the original edition of Bell’s work (‘Beijing Bull,’ The National Interest, Nov-December 2015) and the symposium on Bell in Perspectives on Politics (‘What Exactly Is “The Chinese Ideal?” A Discussion of Daniel A. Bell’s The China Model: Political Meritocracy and the Limits of Democracy’, March 2016)
• The role of informal connections, patronage, and corruption in Russian and Chinese elite politics, and Minxin Pei’s analysis of the degeneration of the PRC elite (Minxin Pei, 'China: From Tiananmen to Neo-Stalinism,' Journal of Democracy, 31/1, January 2020, pp. 154-5)
• The trade-off between loyalty and official tolerance of corruption (see, eg Osipian, Ararat L, 'Loyalty as rent: corruption and politicization of Russian universities,' International journal of sociology and social policy, 2012, Vol.32 (3/4), p.153-167)